Custom Car Shop Owner Arrested for Theft in Huntsville

News Summary

Samuel Matthew Johnson, owner of Smoke Johnson’s Customs in Huntsville, has been arrested for allegedly stealing nearly $135,000 from customers. Complaints began surfacing in early February 2025, with victims claiming they paid for vehicle work that was never completed or parts that were not returned. Despite numerous attempts by customers to contact Johnson, he evaded communication before ultimately being arrested on multiple counts of first-degree theft. The incident has left the local community shocked and concerned about the trustworthiness of auto businesses.

Custom Car Shop Owner Arrested in Huntsville for Alleged Customer Theft

In a stunning turn of events, residents of Huntsville, Alabama, are reeling after learning that a local custom car shop owner has been arrested for stealing a staggering approximately $135,000 from unsuspecting customers. Samuel Matthew Johnson, 38, who ran Smoke Johnson’s Customs on Jack Kendall Way, is facing serious charges after numerous complaints poured in from frustrated car enthusiasts who felt they’d been betrayed.

The Beginning of the Troubles

The complaints started flooding in on February 4, 2025, as several individuals reported that they had paid Johnson for vehicle work that was never completed. From routine modifications to custom paint jobs, it seemed like Johnson had quite the portfolio of promised services. However, the reality was starkly different. Victims told detectives they had made payments totaling around $135,000 for work that simply never happened, or for parts that were never returned after payment.

Victims Speak Out

Each victim came prepared with hard evidence, including receipts and invoices outlining the payments they had made for the services they expected to receive. It’s a frustrating and disheartening situation for many, as they felt hopeful about enhancing their cherished vehicles, only to be left hanging with empty promises.

Attempts to Reach the Owner

In what seems like a nightmare scenario, all victims reported making numerous attempts to contact Johnson, but their messages went unanswered. As if that wasn’t enough, Johnson closed up shop and moved to a new facility in Ardmore while the investigation was just getting underway. One can only imagine the feelings of betrayal and confusion these customers must have felt as they watched the shop they trusted suddenly disappear.

The Investigation Unfolds

As the investigation continued, authorities found it challenging to reach Johnson. Phone calls and messages were ignored, leaving victims and community members longing for answers. It wasn’t until February 13 that detectives took decisive action, executing a search warrant at a storage unit rented by Johnson. What they discovered inside was alarming—a slew of vehicle parts that had either been supplied by victims or ordered but never installed.

Charges and Consequences

With substantial evidence at hand, the Madison County District Attorney’s Office stepped in to review the case. It wasn’t long before warrants were issued for Johnson’s arrest. He now faces five counts of first-degree theft by deception, a charge that could lead to serious legal consequences if he is found guilty. Right now, Johnson is being held at the Madison County Jail on a bond set at $30,000, with many eagerly awaiting the next steps in this troubling saga.

Community Reactions

This incident has shaken the local community, reminding everyone of the importance of choosing reputable businesses. Car enthusiasts in Huntsville have voiced their concerns, urging each other to be diligent and cautious when making significant investments. It’s a harsh reminder that not every business in the auto industry has the customer’s best interests at heart.

What Lies Ahead

As Johnson’s legal situation develops, many are hopeful that the victims will find some semblance of justice. For now, Huntsville residents are left wondering how one local business could go so wrong, leaving a trail of disappointed and angry customers in its wake. Stay tuned for more updates on this unfolding story as it continues to capture the attention of the community.

Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic

HERE Resources

Additional Resources

• WHNT News: Madison County Inmate Killed in Assault at Bessemer Prison
• Wikipedia: Prison Violence
• Iowa Capital Dispatch: County Treasurer Facing a Felony Charge
• Google Search: County Treasurer felony charge
• AOL: Madison County Firefighter Charged with Theft
• Google Scholar: firefighter theft
• Springfield News Sun: Former Clark County EMS Leader Sentenced for Drug Thefts
• Encyclopedia Britannica: Drug Theft
• WBBJ TV: Madison County Mugshots
• Google News: Madison County mugshots